Heir to the Shadows, by Anne Bishop

Buy from Amazon.com or Amazon.ca

Author’s website | Publisher’s website
Publication date – April, 1999

Summary: (Taken from GoodReads) Enough time has passed for the young girl Jaenelle, heir to the magical Darkness, for her physical wounds to heal, while amnesia keeps her frightening memories at bay. But with Saetan–a Black-Jewelled Warlord Prince and Jaenelle’s foster-father–to protect her, she will continue to grow. Her magic will mature. Her memories will return. And Jaenelle will face her destiny when she remembers Daemon, Saetan’s son, who made the ultimate sacrifice for her love….

Thoughts: While it took me forever and a day to finally get around to reading this book, I came away with the feeling that it was definitely better than Daughter of the Blood in many ways, that characters got greater development and many of my initial issues with the first book were resolved satisfactorily. My greater enjoyment of it over the first book was, I admit, rather subjective, since while I did rate the first book decently, I also had many negative memories attached to it that coloured the experience, and since this was the first time I’d moved further in the trilogy’s plot, I had no such experiences to colour this one.

Heir to the Shadows continues Jaenelle’s story, focusing on her teenage years and her struggles with post-rape amnesia and the eventual return of those memories, along with the fact that she holds an insane amount of power that she must also learn to master. Placed under Saetan’s care to keep her from the family that allowed years of abuse to happen, she teeters back and forth between being a relatively normal child (as normal as one can be when they’re being raised by the Lord of Hell, anyway), and being the living embodiment of the power that the Blood hold. Meanwhile, the corruption in Terreille is making its way to Kaeleer, threatening them all.

It’s interesting how Bishop essentially makes a large chunk of a fantasy novel about sexual politics and recovery from sexual trauma, and not only that, but she does it well. Much of the early sections of book that centre on Jaenelle and those around her are very focused on how to handle someone who has undergone a serious trauma but has blocked the memories, knowing that those memories will have the be faced eventually but all of them wanting to keep her from harm for as long as they can. There was a section that particularly impressed me, as it’s something that’s still as relevent today (and often spoken of today) as it was when the book was written.

Then she seemed to shrink into herself. “But, Lucivar,” she said weakly, “what if it’s my fault that he’s aroused and needs relief?”


“You have to service me!” Roxie shouted, pushing herself into a sitting position. “You got me aroused. You have to service me.”

How many times have we heard lines like that appear in recent media and news?

But even aside from the sexual politics and commentary that run throughout the novel, the rest of the actual story is also something that’s well worth reading. Lucivar gets far more page time and development than in Daughter of the Blood, which was nice to see because previously he was someone who showed up for a few scenes and was supposed to be important but didn’t actually play much of a part. Daemon was largely absent, contrary to his very large role in the first books; it’s like he and Lucivar got switched when it came to who to shine the spotlight on. We also get a chance to see the character list expand, with Jaenelle’s friends, and this affords readers the chance to see what a good Queen ought to be, rather than just the looks at corrupted Queens from the first novel.

Heir to the Shadows does a lot of that, really. Comparisons to earlier material, and expansion upon what was previously established. Much occurred in the first book that I felt wasn’t really explained well, or seemed very random and coming out of nowhere. Here, time is devoted to explaining that in greater depth, and not just in pages of exposition for the reader’s benefit or in conversations that characters probably wouldn’t actually have. You can see the evolution of Bishop’s writing already, just between one books and the next. It also gave me a much better appreciation for her ability to world-build; even if it wasn’t explained or presented in the best way early on, all the information about the very complex world and its various cultures was there in her head from the beginning, and realising that gave me a huge amount of respect for her.

Heir to the Shadows turned my opinion of this series from “okay but I may or may not continue with it” to “I really want to finish this trilogy and read the other side novels and short stories.” Aside from occasionally irritating repetition in the text (but hey, everything has its price), the writing has improved noticeably between the first book and the second, the characters have had ample room to grow and develop, and the book’s story ends in such a way that left me wishing I had a copy of the third and final book in the trilogy on my shelves right there and then. It may have been written 15 years ago, but the writing ages well, the issues relative to the real world still stand today as they did then, and it’s an intriguing set of dark fantasy concepts that Bishop plays with here. Very much looking forward to finishing the trilogy now, and I have high hopes for it!

6 comments on “Heir to the Shadows, by Anne Bishop

  1. Thanks, Ria. I read these some years ago. In many ways I think Anne’s Black Jewels novels was a precedessor and trailblazer for authors like,say, Jacqueline Carey, who have gone one to further work in this subgenre

  2. I’ve not read any of her books. I really should. Glad to hear this book has turned the tide of the series.

  3. There is another lesson in this book that also applies as well now as it did then. Family isn’t always comprised of the people you were born to. Real family can be made up of those who love you best.

    Great Review!

    Kiss Kiss

    {Wicked Grin}

    • Yeah, that’s a lesson that took me years to learn on my own (or rather, to stop feeling so freaking guilty about, and to understand that the family of my non-blood family actually likes me and cares about me and isn’t just faking it for some gain that I don’t yet understand… Let it never be said that I didn’t suffer massive insecurity issues). It’s a good lesson to learn!

      Also, “kiss kiss” reminded me of just how much I freaking love Karla! And the way she’ll backtalk Saetan is hilarious to read! :D

  4. Pingback: July in Retrospect | Bibliotropic

  5. Pingback: Looking Back and Forward (2018-2019) | Bibliotropic

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s